For those of you who are butt plug first-timers, we have decided to compile a list combined with our favorites, reader picks, along with the most popular butt plugs on the MQ store. Below is a list of the best butt plugs you can buy in Butt Plugs are a popular tool for anal play , regardless of gender and sexual orientation. Whether you are a beginner or pro, we are going to help you get started. The best butt plug is the Tunnel Anal Plug be cause of its unique design and versitily. The hollow design allows natural airflow and the ability to stretch to different sizes.